Career April 8, 2025

Buyers Agents – Amp Up Your Off-Market Game

 

Create a Unique Value Proposition That Attracts Buyers in Today’s Evolving Real Estate Market

In today’s shifting real estate landscape, buyer prospects are increasingly questioning the role—and value—of buyer’s agents. Many ask, “What do you do to earn tens of thousands in commission?” With easy access to online home listings through Zillow, Realtor.com, and Homes.com, buyers often assume they can find their dream home without agent support.

But as seasoned real estate professionals know, the market is entering a new era: Real Estate 3.0. With changes in Bright MLS policies and the NAR Buyer Brokerage practice guidelines, we’re seeing a surge in off-market listings—properties that aren’t advertised on the MLS but offer real opportunity for savvy agents to shine.

Where Are These Listings Hiding?

Buyer’s agents who want to offer more than portal browsing need to sharpen their skills in sourcing listings beyond the MLS. Off-market opportunities often include:

  • Office Exclusive Listings
  • Pocket Listings
  • FSBOs (For Sale By Owners)
  • Expired Listings
  • Sellers not offering “Buyer Agent Compensation”
  • Zillow, Realtor, and other non-MLS portals

How to Find Off-Market Listings and Build a Powerful Buyer Agent Value Proposition

To stand out and earn your commission, here’s how to become a high-performing buyer’s agent with unmatched value:

1. Leverage Agent-to-Agent Networking

Join a brokerage that encourages collaboration. Build relationships with fellow agents in your office and market area. Share exclusive listings at sales meetings, join roundtable discussions, and exchange information with other full-time real estate agents. Networking opens doors to listings your buyer won’t find online.

2. Monitor Online Portals Strategically

Real estate portals are still useful—but now in a different way. Listings bypassing the MLS may appear on Homes.com, Realtor.com, and others. Set up alerts and monitor new listings closely—especially Office Exclusives with direct-to-agent contact options.

3. Scour FSBO Sites Like a Pro

Savvy agents regularly check:

These are valuable lead sources for real estate professionals serious about helping buyers get ahead of the competition.

4. Become an Open House Regular

Visiting open houses—both public and broker-only—keeps you current and informed. Use open houses to gain firsthand property knowledge and meet listing agents. Show your buyers you’re in the know by staying ahead of upcoming listings.

5. Stay Alert in Your Neighborhood

Great buyer agents are always observing. New yard signs? Agents walking out of a home with a clipboard? These may signal pre-market or expired listings worth investigating.

Your Local Expertise Is Your Superpower

Hyperlocal knowledge is a major selling point for buyers. Full-time agents who specialize in specific counties or towns—like Kent County, Queen Anne’s, Talbot, Caroline, Dorchester, and Cecil County, MD, and Southern Chester County, PA—bring unmatched value. When buyers want an expert, they seek someone who truly knows the area, neighborhoods, pricing, schools, and future development.

“Agents need a rock-solid buyer consultation, communicate their process with confidence, and level up their off-market property skills.”

Set Yourself Apart in Real Estate 3.0

The buyer’s agent role is evolving—and so is the industry. Those who adapt by expanding their off-market strategies and clearly defining their unique value proposition will thrive.

Want to grow your real estate career with a brokerage that supports professional development, local networking, and technology tools for buyer agents? Coldwell Banker Chesapeake Real Estate is here to help.

About the Author

Hugh Smith, ABR, SRS, PSA, RENE, is the Broker of Coldwell Banker Chesapeake Real Estate, serving buyers and sellers in Maryland, Delaware, and Pennsylvania. Licensed since 1983, Hugh leads teams across offices in Easton, Chestertown, and Chesapeake City. He’s a past President of the Mid-Shore Board of Realtors and has received the Maryland Association of Realtors Community Service Award.